Comments on: George Trakas at the Water’s Edge: Newtown Creek

By: Rob Cummings

Rob Cummings — Sun, 10 Jan 2010 13:05:54 +0000

I finally located the path/park yesterday by walking around the poo plant, which is itself an impressive piece of urban infrastructure. There, at the end of Paidge Avenue, was this other-wordly portal glowing in the winter dusk.

I followed the path around the plant, past the cement mixer and rusting backhoes to the water. It was like being transported to the city’s industrial past. The first view of the creek is incredible — the car-crushing yard across water, traffic coursing across the bridges and that silent, dead water.

The next thing I discovered were the steps leading into the water. Amazing to find ghats here in the heart of New York! Further around, in Whale Creek, I was thrilled to find a beautifully landscaped public dock big enough for six or eight cruising vessels.

As a sailor, I’ve lamented the lack of public piers and slips in this harbor town. In years past, you could always find a few intrepid sailors who had tied their boats to the crumbling bulkheads in Newtown Creek, braving the barge traffic and curious pedestrians. So, to find this intentional space for itinerant sailors is marvelous.

So thank you to George Trakas and the DEP for laying out the welcome mat to the world’s sailors. New York may yet regain her reputation as one of the greatest port cities in the world.

By: Hilary Callahan

Hilary Callahan — Sun, 11 Oct 2009 14:28:21 +0000

I went yesterday during Open House New York. The Nature Walk is fantastic. In September I visited the much less enjoyable High Line, and it left a bad taste in my mouth until yesterday when I finally saw some good urban landscape design. What really made my day were my interactions with a gentleman who works at nearby Time-Warner, who loves the place and happily serves as citizen-ambassador for the park. He claims that he goes there every day and was so happy when I mentioned how much I want my son’s school to visit and study the place. I cannot wait for programming there, and I am jealous of those who have visited during snowstorms, etc. Along with the Socrates Sculpture Garden, this is now in my pantheon of Queens greatness.

By: Jean-marc Dufour

Jean-marc Dufour — Tue, 09 Jun 2009 17:09:35 +0000

I'm very happy to have news about Trakas's works, the last time I saw him was in Spring 2000 in south of France near Perpignan during an exhibition (http://www.le-clapotis.net/sculpteurs3/spip.php?article14). I like his works in the town, where the place isn't great at first and became a new point of view in the town, great work.

By: Leslie McBeth

Leslie McBeth — Wed, 22 Apr 2009 16:38:24 +0000

The site is really compelling (almost bizarre) and it’s great to see that it’s receiving some attention.

I live in Greenpoint and I came across it last summer when I was out for a run on an atmospheric rainy day. It was quite an unexpected and adventure-like experience. Running through the ‘vessel’, not knowing where I was going to end up, I was surprised when I found a beautifully landscape path, seating area, little bits of historical information, and steps to access the water at the end. It totally reframed the way that I looked at Newtown Creek, and made me contemplate the idea of the waterway’s potential for recreation and not solely as a polluted industrial site. After running to the end of the trail, I exited through an (unlocked) gate, and ended up inside the sewage treatment plant — I felt like I was not supposed to be there, so I turned and ran back thru the park to the entrance, where upon exiting the site I caught a gorgeous view of the city skyline through the breaking rain clouds. The whole experience was a little surreal, and I made a point to go back.

I didn’t realize that it was actually created through the percent of art program and not a Parks initiative, that makes it all the more interesting. A huge success!

By: Brian Goblik

Brian Goblik — Fri, 17 Apr 2009 08:08:11 +0000

Hurray for George Trakas’s inspiration!
I love water and it’s all around this city, it’s wonderful.
Thank you George, I hope this kind of inspiration catches on with other big city percent for art projects!

By: Deborah Marton

Deborah Marton — Fri, 20 Mar 2009 19:27:42 +0000

To answer your questions:
“Clearly, I’m a fan. Are you?”
I AM NOW.
“I’m curious to hear people’s notions of how public funds for design and construction should incorporate or accommodate art.”
I THINK OUR DEFINITION OF PUBLIC ART IS OUTDATED AND TOO NARROW. I WOULD LIKE TO SEE IT INCLUDE DESIGNED LANDSCAPES COMPREHENSIVELY, AND NOT JUST OBJECTS THAT GET PUT INTO SPACE. TRAKAS’S PROJECT WOULD QUALIFY BY MY DEFINITION.
“Is public access to New York’s waterfronts a citizen’s right or a passing fetish?”
A RIGHT.
“Does the scale of environmental degradation on Newtown Creek render the artistic response to the wastewater treatment facility upgrade seem too-little-too-late?”
NO, IF YOU THINK OF IT AS JUST A START. BUT I COULD SAY A LOT MORE ABOUT THIS.

By: Michael Heimbinder

Michael Heimbinder — Fri, 20 Mar 2009 19:16:25 +0000

New York City is surrounded by water but our shores are often inaccessible – fenced off by industry and underutilized or abandoned properties. The Newtown Creek Nature Walk sets a new precedent for waterfront development, clearly illustrating that industrial and recreational uses can share an important and historic waterway to the benefit of both. In addition, by providing safe access to the Creek, the Nature Walk raises the profile of a long suffering waterway which is a vital first step towards restoring what was once a vibrant tidal estuary teeming with life.

By: Laura Hofmann

Laura Hofmann — Wed, 18 Mar 2009 23:40:03 +0000

Nice film! I love the Nature Walk & am proud to be part of the Newtown Creek Monitoring Committee that worked with George Trakas & DEP on this project. George’s design is everything I hoped it would be. It’s historic, interesting and educational. The Nature Walk has so much to offer the community. It allows us to be right there at the industrial Creek to keep a watchful eye on environmental offenders while enjoying a different type of recreational waterfront use. Even though the Creek has plenty of environmental challenges there’s a beauty about it. During the warm months there are wonderful plantings flourishing here that are drawing more and more small birds. The algae at the bottom of the Creek steps is collecting along with the barnicles, drawing small creatures and waterbirds. My grandkids just love playing with their toys by the rocks and plantings, where there imaginations go wild and those things become jungles and mountains. It’s lots of fun for the kids to see boats, industrial stuff and honking geese all in one visit. The NCWPCP is very cool to see at night. The digester eggs are really cool looking lit up in blue. And there are alot of other cool lighting features to see. In the future when the Nature Walk begins having programming, I’m hoping to see an evening event happen at least once a year to show off the cool lighting and evening water views. My husband & I went to the Nature Walk the first time we had a snow storm. It was crazy weather but well worth the visit. The walk looked awesome.