Underexposed | 1

The city is rife with subtle and strange cues to the complexity that lies beneath our feet and that came before our time, the barely visible mysteries of the landscape we inhabit. Photographer Stanley Greenberg is especially attuned to these. A lifelong New Yorker and erstwhile city employee, he knows New York upside and down, from the newest pipeline to the last remaining Dutch farmhouse. Lately, Greenberg is pursuing an interest in the structures that are grafted into the urban landscape and how they deform it. In the new series, Underexposed, we accompany Greenberg along the myriad paths of the city’s infrastructural networks, as he traces lines of water, gas, and freight transport in great breadth and close detail. -M.M.

Shaft 22, City Tunnel No. 1, Brooklyn. Photo courtesy of Stanley Greenberg

19th century New Yorkers thought the Croton water supply would last forever, but by the 1880s it was clear that a larger supply was needed.  Planners eventually settled on the Catskills as a source, and built the Catskill aqueduct to take water to the Kensico and Hillview reservoirs and then to the city via tunnels. City Tunnel No. 1, completed in 1917, extends the Catskill Aqueduct, traveling from the Bronx to Manhattan and then to Brooklyn, where it ends under Fort Greene Park, not far from the site of this shaft.  A much more impressive structure was built on the Manhattan side, where a mechanism allowed for workers to descend to the tunnel to turn off the water to Brooklyn. Never used, it was destroyed in the early 2000s.

The street grid was disrupted to add an entrance to the Manhattan Bridge near Sands Street, but the shaft remains, unnoticed between street and highway ramp.

Dewatering Apparatus, Shaft 21, City Tunnel No. 1, Location: New York NY. Photo courtesy of Stanley Greenberg

Stanley Greenberg is the author of Time Machines (2011), Under Construction (2010), Waterworks: A Photographic Journey Through New York’s Hidden Water System (2003), and Invisible New York: The Hidden Infrastructure of the City (1998). Greenberg was born in Brooklyn, New York, and lives there now.

The views expressed here are those of the authors only and do not reflect the position of The Architectural League of New York.



Photographer Stanley Greenberg’s monthly dispatches trace the myriad paths of the city’s infrastructural networks in great breadth and close detail.